Why Do a Few Trades Make All My Profit?
Find out how much of your profit, and of your losses, comes from just a few trades.
Check My ConcentrationA common shape for a trading account is a few big winners and many small trades that roughly cancel out. It can be a sign of a healthy approach that lets winners run, or a sign of luck. The total looks the same either way, which is why it is worth looking underneath.
If a handful of trades produce nearly all your profit, then removing them leaves very little. Your results depend on being in the right place a few times, and whether you can repeat that is an open question. A month without one of those trades looks nothing like a month with one.
The same holds for losses. When a few trades produce most of the damage, the problem is not your many ordinary trades but the exceptions, such as a stop that was not honored or a position that was too large. Fixing those few has more effect than improving everything else.
The analyzer ranks your trades and measures what share of your gross profit comes from the top tenth, and what share of your gross loss comes from the worst tenth. It reports each when the share is high.
Drop your trade history CSV here
Closed positions or P&L history from your exchange. Up to 5 MB.
Your file is read in memory and is never saved — only the result of the analysis is kept (7 days, or until you delete it if you save it to your account). Don't include passwords or API keys. See the Privacy Policy.
Example — not your data
Example result
Trades analyzed
30
Top 3 trades' share of gross profit
The top tenth of 30 trades
95%
Reading
Almost all the profit comes from three trades
Illustrative numbers for a made-up account, shown so you know what a result looks like. They are not your data and not a benchmark.
What is measured
The top tenth of trades
Their combined profit as a share of all your winning trades' profit.
The worst tenth of trades
Their combined loss as a share of all your losing trades' loss.
The threshold
A share of 60% or more is reported, with at least 20 trades in the file.
Reading the result
Concentrated profit is not bad in itself. It tells you how much weight the results rest on. For where losses come from by coin, see which crypto loses you the most.
Frequently asked questions
Is it normal for a few trades to make most of the profit?
It is common, especially for strategies that cut losses and let winners run. It becomes a concern when it is combined with a low win rate and few trades, because then the result may rest on chance. The numbers in the report let you judge how much weight to give it.
What should I do if a few trades cause most of my losses?
Look at what those trades have in common: a size larger than usual, a stop that was not honored, a time of day, or an instrument. The pattern in the large losses is usually more useful than the average loss.
Why does it use the top tenth?
A tenth is large enough to be stable and small enough to show concentration. Using a fixed share of your trades, not a fixed count, keeps the comparison fair whether you have 30 trades or 3,000.
Which file should I upload?
A CSV where each row is one finished trade with its result: your exchange's closed positions or profit-and-loss history. It needs a close time and a result, or entry price, exit price, quantity and side. A list of individual order fills is not enough, because fills cannot be paired into trades without guessing.
Is my trade history stored?
The file is read in memory and is not saved. Only the result of the analysis is kept: for 7 days if you do not sign in, or until you delete it if you save it to your account. The analyzer never asks for exchange passwords or API keys.
Keep going
Analyzers
Trading Performance Analyzer
Trading problems
Which Crypto Loses Me the Most Money?
Trading problems
Why Do I Keep Losing Money Trading?
Trading problems
Why Are My Losses Bigger Than My Wins?
Trading problems
Am I Better at Long or Short Trades?
Analyzers
Trade Holding Time Analyzer
Learn
How to Draw the Right Conclusions from Your Own Trading Data
Learn
If-Then Rules: Turn Trading Insight into Discipline
Holdy Lab content is educational and is not financial advice. Results describe the data you provide; they do not predict future results.