Holdy Labs

Am I Better at Long or Short Trades?

Compare the win rate and net result of your longs and your shorts.

Compare My Longs and Shorts

Most traders have a direction they prefer, and it is usually not the one that serves them best. Buying feels natural, because it matches how people think about investing. Shorting feels like going against the crowd, and many people take shorts at the wrong moments, such as after a sharp fall, when the move is already over.

The numbers can look very different in the two directions. It is common for one side to carry the account while the other quietly gives profit back. If your longs make money and your shorts lose it, the account looks fine in total and hides a simple fix: take fewer shorts, or only the ones that fit a clear rule.

The reverse also happens, and the lesson is the same. Without the split, you cannot tell whether you have an edge in a direction or only in a market phase. A strong run of longs in a rising market says little about your skill at longs.

If your file records the side of each trade, the analyzer separates your longs from your shorts and compares trades, win rate and net result. It reports a finding when the two sides differ clearly and there are enough trades on each.

Drop your trade history CSV here

Closed positions or P&L history from your exchange. Up to 5 MB.

Your file is read in memory and is never saved — only the result of the analysis is kept (7 days, or until you delete it if you save it to your account). Don't include passwords or API keys. See the Privacy Policy.

Example — not your data

Example result

Longs

30 trades

+380.00 · 58% win rate

Shorts

14 trades

−210.00 · 31% win rate

Reading

Longs are carrying the account

Illustrative numbers for a made-up account, shown so you know what a result looks like. They are not your data and not a benchmark.

What the comparison covers

Trades, win rate and net result

For longs and for shorts separately, so you can see which direction is carrying the account.

A sample on both sides

At least 10 trades in each direction are needed, so a handful of shorts cannot create a conclusion.

What counts as different

Win rates at least 15 points apart, or one direction profitable while the other loses.

The market phase

A directional edge in your data may simply reflect a rising or falling market. Check the dates in the result before reading it as skill.

Frequently asked questions

Should I stop shorting if my shorts lose money?

That is a decision for you, and the data alone does not make it. The comparison shows how your shorts have performed. Whether to stop, to change how you take them, or to wait for more history depends on how many trades support it and what the market was doing.

How does the analyzer know which trades are long and which are short?

It reads the side column in your file, accepting long and short, or buy and sell. If your exchange reports the closing order's side instead of the position's, the labels can be reversed, so check a trade or two against your records.

What if I only trade one direction?

Then there is nothing to compare, and this check is skipped. The analyzer still reports your performance and the other patterns for the trades you have.

Which file should I upload?

A CSV where each row is one finished trade with its result: your exchange's closed positions or profit-and-loss history. It needs a close time and a result, or entry price, exit price, quantity and side. A list of individual order fills is not enough, because fills cannot be paired into trades without guessing.

Is my trade history stored?

The file is read in memory and is not saved. Only the result of the analysis is kept: for 7 days if you do not sign in, or until you delete it if you save it to your account. The analyzer never asks for exchange passwords or API keys.

Keep going

Holdy Lab content is educational and is not financial advice. Results describe the data you provide; they do not predict future results.